25 Comments

So proud to be an official Black Sheep! Thank you, Jake and Salomé. Such important work you’re doing creating a space for thoughtful opinion and debate.

Expand full comment

Thanks, Alta. Yes, the commodification of identities is a great way to put it -- spot on! Thanks for reading, and I look forward to reading your work too.

Expand full comment

This dynamic is in play on both left and right, by the way

Expand full comment

Absolutely. These machiavellian tactics are a hallmark of authoritarianism, which can go left or right, as you said.

Appreciate your comment and really thrilled you came across my publication. I'm a huge admirer of your work!

Expand full comment

Thanks, Robert. Yes, without doubt!

Expand full comment

Exactly. They mirror each other’s tactics so clearly.

Expand full comment

True. It’s non denominational.

Expand full comment

A very well written and necessary essay. I was familiar with many of the cases of identity fraud presented here, but this is a very good summary, which asks some very good questions. And these stories of griftivism need to be repeated over and over until they are etched in everyone's consciousness. This insanity is the result of a society that commodifies identities. This didn't start yesterday: it started on American campuses decades ago, but it took a long time for people to notice.

Expand full comment

Glad you enjoyed this one Alta. And yes, repeating these examples until they become part of the mainstream culture's consciousness is exactly the goal!

Expand full comment

Fantastic essay! I don’t know what it is about Australian culture that makes it easy to cry victim, but my experiences of smear campaign and failed attempts to cancel me led me to conceptualise & describe the communal narcissist called the Social INjustice Warrior. It’s great so many more people are able to spot these destructive people posing as wounded saints.

Expand full comment

Thank you, Nathalie. The Social INjustice Warrior -- love that! Wonderful to connect and I will read up on your work.

Expand full comment

Thank you! Looking forward to reading more of your work! From my knowledge of the poetry communities in the US, what you describe is common.

Expand full comment

Oh no! I was hoping it was just prevalent in the insular Aussie poetry scene. But of course, it’s probably Western-worldwide. Poetry Magazine, the Chicago-based Mecca of poetry, is a shell of itself after one of its former editor, Don Share, was taken down in the madness of 2020. A lovely man who genuinely supported poetry from all corners of the globe :(

Expand full comment

Without even reading the article, the title sums up the whole city of San Francisco and its funding of homelessness, drug using, etc businesses/”NonProfits” - modern graft to the tune of $1billion/yr

Expand full comment

It’s sad to hear that! Killing with ‘kindness’ indeed.

Expand full comment

Good point!

Expand full comment

Well researched and argued. I’m concerned that today’s young adults really can get caught in massive internet peerage networks where there is no calm adult in the room. These cancellations are symbolic violence…a symbolic version of Lord of The Flies.

Expand full comment

Thanks, James. ‘Symbolic violence’ — that’s spot on. I wish there were more ‘adults’ in the room who were willing/able to take a risk and stick their heads above the parapet in order to show a better way. I’m a bit disappointed in my generation (X), to be honest — we cower too easily!

Expand full comment

This is a great piece

Expand full comment

Cheers! Thanks, Paul.

Expand full comment

Glad you read this one! It really does a great job of breaking down an unusual new phenomenon.

Expand full comment

“Griftivist”- love it 😊.

The grift is massive in Australia.

There’s a lot of monetisation towards the most vulnerable people who are exploited for their own monetary gain & to grab at social brownie points. I’ve personally been on the receiving end of it.

I’ve also been cancelled/shadow banned for not being woke enough. The callous way that people have used me and no doubt others too, is heinously revolting thing to be subjected to. Hypocritical grubs.

One of the best things we’ve got going for us right now is that Elon has bought Xitter. This has caused an uproar among the woke and levelled the playing field for the rest of us.

Now EVERYONE gets to have a say. I don’t really even bother arguing with them because it’s far more satisfying to leave them on read. Narcissists love attention no matter if positive or negative as long as they get it.

And being a griftivist is the most narcissistic thing a person can do.

Expand full comment

Thanks, Tziporah. Sorry to hear you’ve also been on the receiving end! I agree -- Twitter is much more balanced now that Elon is running the show. It’s still a dumpster fire, but at least all sides get a go. Thanks for reading ‘Griftivism’. Really appreciate your feedback.

Expand full comment

Does this also go for anti-abortion activists and Moms for Liberty activists and anti-woke activists like Chris Rufo? It pretty clearly does.

Expand full comment

Hi Brian, I’d say so. Perhaps only wearing a different face.

Expand full comment
Error